In one of the most heartwarming and unexpected stories of the 2025 U.S. Open Cup, a group of retired Major League Soccer (MLS) All-Stars have dusted off their boots for one final ride representing none other than the Des Moines Menace. What started as a nostalgic idea has turned into a serious competitive run, powered by familiar names from American soccer’s golden era.

Spearheaded by former U.S. international Benny Feilhaber, the initiative reunites a band of seasoned warriors including Sacha Kljestan, Bradley Wright-Phillips, Dax McCarty, Osvaldo Alonso, and Matt Hedges. With hundreds of MLS appearances and international caps among them, they’ve injected star power, grit, and flair into a Menace side that has suddenly become must-watch.

Feilhaber, who masterminded the group’s assembly, saw it as a chance to relive the spirit of competition and camaraderie that once defined their playing days. “It wasn’t just about playing again,” he noted. “It was about doing it together one last run, with the guys you shared the grind with.”

That spirit was on full display in their opening match. Facing chants mocking their age and fitness, the Menace leaned on experience and tactical nous. Sacha Kljestan, ice-cold as ever, converted a crucial penalty in the 57th minute, reminding everyone why he was one of the league’s most composed midfielders.

Their dream continued into the second round, where they faced Sporting Kansas City II. With Bradley Wright-Phillips back in competitive play, the Menace pulled off a gritty 2-1 victory. Wright-Phillips, who played 65 minutes, showed flashes of his former self the same sharpness that once made him a two-time MLS Golden Boot winner.

Beyond the goals and results, this improbable run has reignited national interest in the U.S. Open Cup, a tournament known for its romantic upsets and cross-generational clashes. The presence of these retired legends has drawn fans back to the grassroots, proving that the love for the game never truly retires.

As the Menace prepare for the next chapter in their journey, supporters across the country are watching with growing admiration and curiosity. Win or lose, these MLS icons have already left a mark showing that while careers may end, the passion to compete never fades. This is more than a comeback. It’s a celebration of legacy, loyalty, and the beautiful game.