Aston Villa have submitted a formal complaint to the Premier League and PGMOL following a controversial refereeing decision that played a pivotal role in their 2-0 loss to Manchester United on the final day of the 2024–25 Premier League season. The decision, which saw a Morgan Rogers goal disallowed for an alleged foul on United goalkeeper Altay Bayindir, effectively denied Villa a place in next season’s Champions League.

Disallowed Goal Sparks Outrage

The incident occurred in the 73rd minute with the game level at 0-0. Rogers appeared to have legally dispossessed Bayindir and scored, only for referee Thomas Bramall to whistle for a foul before the ball crossed the line. Since the play was stopped before the ball entered the net, VAR could not intervene, leading to widespread frustration and criticism.

Replays suggested the goalkeeper had not secured full control of the ball, casting doubt over the decision. Former referee Peter Walton remarked that Bramall should have allowed play to continue to enable VAR review.

Villa's Complaint Targets Referee Selection

Villa’s Director of Football Operations, Damian Vidagany, clarified that the club's issue is less with the specific call and more with the appointment of an inexperienced referee for such a critical fixture. Bramall, 35, was among the least experienced officials available and was officiating a match that directly impacted European qualification for multiple teams.

“The complaint is about the selection of referees,” said Vidagany. “One of the most inexperienced referees was given one of the most difficult matches of the season.”

Unai Emery and Player Reactions

Villa manager Unai Emery echoed the frustration, stating, “With that goal, maybe we get a better result and reach the Champions League.” Team captain John McGinn called the ruling “incredible” and criticized current VAR protocols, calling for reform.

European Football Implications

The disallowed goal proved decisive. Just minutes later, Manchester United scored twice to seal the result. Villa, who only needed a point to secure fourth, instead dropped to sixth on goal difference, consigning them to a Europa League berth.

This single officiating decision arguably reshaped the European qualification landscape for the 2025–26 season.

Premier League Responds to VAR Debate

The Premier League later confirmed that VAR had no jurisdiction over the decision because the referee blew his whistle before the ball crossed the line. This has reignited debate around VAR rule limitations and the need for revised guidelines in such high-stakes situations.

 
The controversy surrounding Thomas Bramall’s decision and Aston Villa’s formal complaint has spotlighted significant flaws in referee selection and VAR application. As calls grow for greater accountability and clarity, this incident may catalyze long-overdue changes in Premier League officiating standards.

Subscribe to our newsletter for more exclusive soccer stories, match breakdowns, and rising star features from around the world.